Caution regarding fixed express slings

In July 2022, a climbing rope at the Götterwandl near Nassereith was almost severed at a worn carabiner. Why fixed quickdraws are so dangerous – and what to do about it.
Fast durchtrenntes Kletterseil nach Kontakt mit eingeschliffenem Karabiner
Fast durchtrenntes Kletterseil nach Kontakt mit eingeschliffenem Karabiner

Never blindly trust Fixem products

In July 2022, an extremely dangerous incident occurred at the Götterwandl crag near Nassereith: a climbing rope was almost severed at a worn carabiner on a fixed quickdraw.

Reason enough to once again draw attention, in no uncertain terms, to the danger that can be posed by permanently fixed slings. Unfortunately, the bad habit of leaving permanent quickdraws hanging in climbing areas for years on end is all too common. So please be aware of this potential danger – and make sure you draw your friends’ attention to it!

Why can fixed express loops be so dangerous?

With permanently fixed quickdraws, the rope repeatedly runs over the same spot on the rope-side carabiner, wearing it down from the side. With standard aluminium carabiners, this leads to extremely sharp edges over time. Consequently, even the slightest strain can cause cuts in the rope’s sheath – for example, when simply ‘clipping’ into the rope. If you fall into such a carabiner, it can even lead to the rope breaking!

Diagram: Rope route over the inner ridge of the carabiner

History of serious accidents

From 2008 onwards, serious accidents began to occur, initially in indoor climbing centres: first at a climbing centre in Prague, where the rope snapped at the 1. bolt. In 2010, a similar pattern emerged in an incident at the Red River Gorge (USA). Then, in 2012, came the tragic culmination – a fatal accident in Magletsch, Switzerland, caused by a rope snap.

Worn aluminium carabiner with a sharp edge

How can this risk be addressed?

A few simple codes of conduct can improve safety on the rock when it comes to fixed quickdraws:

  • NEVER ‘blindly trust’ fixed gear.
  • If you find fixed gear on a route, you should always clip in your own quickdraws.
  • In affected areas, please speak to other (inexperienced) climbers about the danger.
  • Simply remove your own gear – and don’t place any fixed quickdraws on the routes in the first place.
  • Anyone who finds such quickdraws should remove them and, in the interests of fairness, leave them at the foot of the wall for the owner to collect.
  • If you absolutely need fixed quickdraws for your projects, you should use steel carabiners on the rope side.
Permanently installed quickdraws on a climbing route

All fixed express routes are being removed!

As there is clearly an ‘imminent danger’ on the Götterwandl, all fixed quickdraws will be removed from 14 August. Please therefore remove your quickdraws from the routes yourself beforehand. The removed quickdraws can, of course, be collected later: they will be stored at the TVB office in Nassereith and can be collected there during opening hours.

Further reading:ÖAV press release and the detailed technical article from bolting.eu entitled ‘Worn carabiners – risk of rope breakage’.

You might also be interested in these articles